Do you want to go straight to a particular resource? Use the Jump Tool and follow 2 steps:
This can usually be found in the top hero section of overview, delegations visualize, session visualize, event visualize, commentary collection, commentary item, resource collection, and resource item pages.
Enter the shortcut code for the page that you wish to search for.
These documents were scanned, collated and catalogued by Ruth Murray, Annabel Harris, Isha Pareek, Eleanor Williams, Antoine Yenk, Harriet Carter, Oliver Nicholls, Kieran Wetherwick, and Cerys Griffiths.
Collection associations (0)
None
Already have an account? Login here
Don't have an account? Register here
Forgot your password? Click here to reset it
None
None
Copyright
None
Physical Copy Information
None
Digital Copy Information
None
HCS/12/22
FROM: SIR K P BLOOMFIELD DATE: 10 DECEMBER 1990
PUS (L&B) - B
A MODEST PROPOSAL
I have been reflecting carefully on the view of the GOC that, in the right circumstances, an introduction of internment on both sides of the Border could do much to bring the PIRA campaign to an end. When this was discussed, I shared the general Office view that Irish agreement was in foreseeable circumstances most unlikely, and that a unilateral internment by us - whatever short-term impediment it might place in the way of terrorism - was only too likely to reinforce sympathy for republicanism in Ireland and revive dormant anti-British feeling abroad, particularly in America.
We are in a situation, however, in which we should try to visualise currently unforeseeable circumstances (if that is not an Irishism). Our own last comprehensive exposition of the Office perception, the "Defeating Terrorism" document, looked for an end to the campaign much more to a recognition of its unwinnability by PIRA than to a classic military defeat. Some of the other circumstances in Ireland are favourable to the application of moral pressure to the Provisional movement. The election of President Robinson and the installation of Archbishop Daly are bringing a new mood to the country. The Secretary of State's "Whitbread speech" has positioned us to take advantage of that mood.
Yet PIRA remain replete with weaponry and far from short of skilled men and women. With all its vast superiority in numbers, the Army reflects a growing pessimism. We are more than 20 years into "the troubles"; there is no end in sight.
If our assumption is that PIRA will crumble one day and withdraw from the battlefield, then we need give no special thought to prisoners other than as criminals who will serve out their sentenced subject only to the normal processes of review. But if, on the other hand we seek to persuade PIRA to disengage without militarily crushing them, the position of prisoners is crucial.
We have declared that there can be no question of talking to PIRA/Sinn Fein while violence continues. I do not think this can be allowed to mean that dialogue at a distance is inconceivable.
In our relations with the Irish we see little sign that they are willing to join with us in any action which would radically change and substantially improve the situation.
What, then, if we were to speak to the Irish as follows? The violence in Northern Ireland has been going on for over two decades, and we do not believe it can be permitted to continue indefinitely. Will you, then, join with us in presenting to PIRA a final opportunity to get themselves off the hook of violence? We could say to them jointly, and through the Conference; "You are impeding progress towards a resolution of the problems in Ireland. We call upon you to stop the violence. If you respond positively to this call, and we are satisfied that violence has stopped, after [one month] the UK Government will begin to release prisoners, giving priority to the cases of those who were youngest when sentenced and whose crimes did not result in death or serious injury to others. A continuation of this violence-free period will lead to a progressive review of other cases, with a view to the ultimate release of all prisoners sentenced by Diplock Courts [save those who have been found guilty of murder]. But if there is not a positive response from PIRA to this call for the ending of violence, both Governments will regard PIRA as being in a state of war against Irish people North and South, and will use to the extent necessary in both parts of Ireland powers of executive detention."
A very high risk strategy? Of course it is. But if we cannot envisage the military defeat of PIRA by means which do not include internment, and if we cannot envisage introducing internment in the face of opposition from the Irish Government and international opinion, by what means do we persuade or force PIRA to desist?
(SIGNED)
K P BLOOMFIELD
27 1988 - 2023
38 1993 - 1993
55 101 - 1991
64 1993 - 2020
26 1993 - 1993
57 1993 - 1993
59 1993 - 1993
51 1993 - 1993
18 1993 - 1993
24 1993 - 1994
41 1993 - 1994
32 1993 - 1994
72 101 - 1994
8 101 - 1990
76 101 - 1994
1 1994
60 101 - 1994
65 1993 - 2023
37 101 - 1993
54 101 - 1993
32 101 - 1993
77 1993 - 1993
58 101 - 2018
49 1993 - 1997
61 101 - 1992
38 101 - 1991
48 1992 - 1993
134 101 - ?-??
59 101 - 2023
84 101 - 1993
64 101 - 1991
44
11
31 1996 - 1996
61 1996 - 1996
49 1996 - 1996
20 1996 - 1997
32 1996 - 1996
48 1996 - 1996
74 1996 - None
4 1996 - 1996
33 1996 - 1996
30 1996 - 1996
7 1996 - 1996
24 1996 - 1996
9 1996 - 1996
59 1996 - 1996
60 1996 - 1996
14 1996 - 1997
41 1996 - 1996
45 1996 - 1996
67 1996 - 1996
16 1996 - 1996
87 1996 - None
23 1996 - 1996
79 1996 - None
22 1996 - 1996
1990-12-10
In this memo, addressed to John Chilcot, Kenneth Bloomfield reflects on different options available to the British Government with regards to prisoners, with the specific aim of ending PIRA's campaign. He outlines the problems with introducing internment and proposes a joint statement with the Irish Government which would ask PIRA to cease paramilitary activity in exchange for the gradual review and release of prisoners. He also notes that the proposal would state that PIRA's refusal would compel the Irish and British Governments to reinstate internment. The first page includes some annotated notes.
No Associations
N/A
N/A
Unless otherwise specified, this material falls under Crown Copyright and contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
The National Archives of the UK (TNA), digitzed by the Quill Project at https://quillproject.net/resource_collections/351/.