Search Results

Overview
North Dakota State Constitutional Convention 1889 [updated-6.1 v3]

Constitution Writing in the American West (NEH)

The Proceedings and Debates of the Constitutional Convention of North Dakota from July to August of 1889.

Cite as: Cashlyn English, Gwen Wilde, Jordan Artigas, Kaylee Bishop, Liné Fourie, Grace Yeager, Nicholas Cole, Elizabeth Green, Lauren Davis , North Dakota State Constitutional Convention 1889 [updated-6.1 v3], Quill Project at Pembroke College (Oxford, 2020-2023).

Jump To
q247
People Icon97 People
Procedures Icon1068 Procedures
Documents Icon400 Documents
Decisions Icon2057 Decisions

Introduction

The Constitution of North Dakota (1889) was written from July to August of 1889. The so-called ‘Omnibus’ Enabling Act of 1889 permitted the splitting up of the Territory of Dakota into two states, as well as the admittance of Montana and Washington into the Union. Following the passage of the Enabling Act, 75 delegates from 25 districts met at Bismarck on July 4 to draft the state’s foundational text.

Unlike the South Dakota Convention, which used the articles of the Sioux Falls constitution as the basis of the drafting process, North Dakota approached constitution-writing with a more open proposition format. Individual delegates presented files on specific subjects, which were numbered and referred to one, or occasionally multiple, of the 23 standing committees established to consider propositions relevant to their area of expertise. These committees prepared reports on the propositions in which they recommended indefinite postponement, adoption, amendment, or a substitute proposition on the same subject. These reports were then referred to the Convention to be taken up in the Committee of the Whole. The Committee of the Whole considered the standing committee reports, and drafted its own reports either recommending the adoption of the standing committee reports, or offering its own recommendations on the proposition or propositions under consideration. The Convention then voted to adopt or reject the Committee of the Whole’s recommendations. When a report recommending the passage of a particular file was adopted, the file in question was referred to the Committee on Revision and Adjustment, whose duty it was to order the propositions into a draft constitution, whilst ensuring that no one part of the Constitution conflicted with any other. The draft constitution was sent back to the Convention, where it was amended and voted upon section-by-section for the final time. Successful articles were ultimately enrolled as the Constitution of North Dakota, approved by the Convention, and ratified on October 1, 1889.

To construct the Quill timeline, the editors consulted the Proceedings and Debates of the First Constitutional Convention of North Dakota, and the Journal of the Constitutional Convention for North Dakota. Where relevant, both sources have been used to corroborate the events in the timeline. A full list of source materials can be found on the “Full Record” view. Future editions of this project could incorporate the accounts of the proceedings published in other contemporary newspapers as well.

Users may be interested in the how pieces of proposed constitutional text circulated throughout the Convention. This procedure is captured in a document event’s “Related Events” tab. A more general overview of documents’ journeys throughout the Convention is provided by the “Calendar View”. This negotiation is notable for the flurry of external petitions, received by the Convention in its final days, upon the subject of its controversial decision to designate the location of state institutions within the constitution. The “Document Library” view provides a zoomed out look at all documents that were introduced in the Convention and will be compelling to those users who are approaching the project with an interest in particular documents.

Elizabeth Green

Documentary Editor

Quill Project

Pembroke College, Oxford.

July 2023.

Full Record View

This page shows the complete source-material for this negotiation

Guided Research Tools

This page gives access to the main visualizations used to explore the work of committees or individuals

Voting Statistics

This view offers a set of tools to examine shifting alliances

Topic Overview

This view shows a summary of the topic keywords associated with events during this negotiation, and allows users to find events associated with each keyword

Activity Summary

This page offers a series of views for exploring the work of those involved in this process of negotiation, focusing on the hierarchical relationship of proposals rather than on the sequence of events

Document Library

This page shows the documents currently agreed to or under consideration by various committees. A good tool for those using Quill in meeting presentations.

Sessions Calendar View

Sessions Chart

To see the full record of a committee, click on the corresponding committee on the map below

Preparing Visualisation - please wait

Negotiation Statistics

Sources

4 historical records used for this dataset.

Process

36 committees met in 247 sessions.

Average 61.75 sessions each.

Dates

Dates from Thursday, 04 July 1889 to Saturday, 17 August 1889.

People

97 people in 25 voting delegations.

Top 5 most active people are:

Summary of person events:

  • Person join icon 428 join a committee.
  • Person leave icon leave a committee.
  • Person elect icon 129 elections to a position.

Procedures

1068 procedural motions considered.

Summary of procedural events:

  • Procedural motion icon 1068 procedural motion proposed.
  • Debate motion icon 103 motions debated.

Documents

400 documents considered with 862 amendments presented.

Summary of document events:

  • Create a new document proposal 400 new documents created.
  • Document copied 483 documents passed from another committee.
  • Document amended 862 amendments to a document proposed.
  • Debate a document proposal 263 debates on a proposal.

Decisions

2057 number of decisions made.

Summary of decision made:

  • Vote adopt icon 1346 proposals adopted.
  • Vote reject icon 228 proposals rejected.
  • Vote refer icon 351 proposals referred to another committee.
  • Postpone debate icon 5 debate of a proposal postponed.
  • Vote drop icon 44 proposal dropped from discussion without a formal vote.
  • Vote drop icon 2 some other decision on a proposal.

List of proposals by delegation

List of proposals by person

North Dakota Journal

A collection of the North Dakota Journal from the 1889 Constitutional Convention.

North Dakota Debates

A collection of the North Dakota Debates from the 1889 Constitutional Convention.

North Dakota Newspaper: The Bismarck Weekly Tribune

A collection of the digital scans of the original newspaper, the Bismarck Weekly Tribune, for the record of the North Dakota Constitutional Convention 1889.

North Dakota Newspaper: The Hope Pioneer

A collection of the digital scans of the original newspaper, the Hope Pioneer, for the record of the North Dakota Constitutional Convention 1889.

North Dakota Newspaper: Oakes Weekly Republican

A collection of the digital scans of the original newspaper, the Oakes Weekly Republican, for the record of the North Dakota Constitutional Convention 1889.

North Dakota Newspaper: The Dickinson Press

A collection of the digital scans of the original newspaper, the Dickinson Press, for the record of the North Dakota Constitutional Convention 1889.

There are no commentaries for this negotiation yet!